Britain's food and drink magazineThursday 19 November 2026

The best mince pies and Christmas puddings for 2026: what the taste tests say

What the 2026 taste tests from Good Housekeeping, woman&home and the Independent say about supermarket mince pies and Christmas puddings, with prices checked on 12 November 2026.

A tray of freshly baked mince pies with pastry star toppings
Photo: Dan Counsell / Unsplash

The best supermarket mince pie of 2026 depends on whose taste test you read: the Good Housekeeping Institute put Aldi’s Specially Selected Mince Pies first, while the Independent and woman&home both chose Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference All Butter Mince Pies. For Christmas pudding, Good Housekeeping’s 2026 winner is Aldi’s Specially Selected 24 Month Matured Christmas Pudding, which Aldi currently lists at £6.99.

We have not tasted these ourselves. This guide brings together the 2026 taste tests published so far, each credited and linked, alongside current prices. Prices checked 12 November 2026.

Which taste tests is this guide based on?

Three publications have released 2026 results for mince pies, and two for Christmas puddings. Which? has not yet published its 2026 results, so we include its 2025 mince pie verdict and say so wherever it appears.

TestPublishedHow it was judged
Good Housekeeping Institute Christmas Taste Test 202613 October 2026Blind tasting of 42 mince pies and 26 Christmas puddings, scored out of 100
woman&home Christmas Food Awards 202628 October 2026Blind tasting by the magazine’s food team and guest judges, with category winners
The Independent (IndyBest)5 November 2026Blind tasting of supermarket mince pies, rated out of 5
Which? best mince pies 202518 November 2025Expert panel blind-tasted premium supermarket mince pies

Which supermarket mince pies are best in 2026?

Two names come up most often. Aldi won Good Housekeeping’s classic category, and Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference won both the Independent’s test and woman&home’s supermarket award.

Good Housekeeping gave Aldi Specially Selected Mince Pies 86/100, describing them as “Rich, fruity and gently spiced; testers compared this pie’s festive aroma to a glass of mulled wine.” Aldi lists a pack of six at £1.39, or about 23p a pie.

The Independent named Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference All Butter Mince Pies its best overall, rating them 4.5/5 and calling them “the best we tried”. At woman&home, Group Food Director Jen Bedloe said: “These nostalgic pies are everything you want in a mince pie, wonderfully buttery pastry paired with juicy, boozy vine fruits.”

How do the 2026 mince pies compare?

The table below lists every mince pie that won a category or a top rating in the 2026 tests. Prices marked with an asterisk (*) are the prices the testers quoted, because we could not load the retailer’s own product page to confirm the current price. Check before you shop.

Mince piesRetailerPricePackWhat the testers saidSource
Specially Selected Mince PiesAldi£1.39686/100, best supermarket mince pie and best value; 3/5 and “best budget” at the IndependentGood Housekeeping, the Independent
Taste the Difference All Butter Mince PiesSainsbury’s£3.50*64.5/5, best overall; best supermarket mince pies; 73/100 at Good HousekeepingThe Independent, woman&home, Good Housekeeping
Brownie and the Bean Mince PiesBrownie and the Bean£13.50* including delivery486/100, best bakery mince pie; best luxury mince piesGood Housekeeping, woman&home
Finest Amaretto Mince PiesTesco£3*485/100, best flavoured mince pieGood Housekeeping
Irresistible Amaretto & Frangipane Mince PiesCo-op£2.85*484/100, best for frangipane fansGood Housekeeping
Free From Milk & Gluten Free Mince PiesWaitrose£2.80*284/100, best gluten-free mince pieGood Housekeeping
Collection Mince PiesM&S (online at Ocado)£3.50*64.5/5, best for fillingThe Independent
No.1 Brown Butter Mince Pies with CognacWaitrose£2.66 to £3.20*64/5, best luxury; 80/100; Which?’s favourite in 2025The Independent, Good Housekeeping, Which?
Exceptional Luxury Mince PiesAsda£2.84*64/5, best for spices; poorest on test at Which? in 2025The Independent, Which?
Large Sharing Mince PieAbel & Cole£14.001 pie, 8 to 10 servings80/100, best sharing mince pieGood Housekeeping
Jewelled Mince Pie TartsTesco£5*2Best alternative mince pieswoman&home
Free From Mince PiesCo-op£2.25*4Best free from mince pieswoman&home

The Waitrose price range reflects two different quotes: the Independent listed the pack at £2.66 and Good Housekeeping at £3.20.

Why do the mince pie taste tests disagree?

Each panel weighs different things. Good Housekeeping scored aroma, flavour and appearance; the Independent also looked at value and how original a pie looked.

That shows in the results. Aldi’s pies topped Good Housekeeping’s test but scored 3/5 with the Independent, whose testers felt there was “too much pastry compared to filling”, while still praising the value at 25p a pie. Sainsbury’s pies won the Independent’s test but scored 73/100 with Good Housekeeping, below the leaders.

If two tests agree, that is a stronger signal than any single score. On that basis, Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference (two category wins) and Brownie and the Bean (top marks at Good Housekeeping and best luxury at woman&home) are the safest bets.

Which are the best luxury and flavoured mince pies?

For a treat, Brownie and the Bean was the stand-out. One Good Housekeeping tester called it “a really, really great mince pie”, and Ruth Langsford, judging for woman&home, said: “This has a lovely salted butter flavour”.

Among supermarket options, amaretto is the flavour of the year. Tesco Finest Amaretto Mince Pies scored 85/100 with Good Housekeeping, with one tester declaring them “just what I want from a mince pie”, and Co-op’s Irresistible Amaretto & Frangipane pies scored 84/100.

Waitrose No.1 Brown Butter Mince Pies with Cognac were the Independent’s best luxury pick. Its reviewer found them the booziest of the test, though said the filling “could have been more generous”.

What are the best gluten-free mince pies?

Good Housekeeping’s best gluten-free pie was Waitrose Free From Milk & Gluten Free Mince Pies (84/100), with testers praising the “perfectly crisp, rich pastry”.

At woman&home, Co-op Free From Mince Pies won the free from category. Food writer Lucy Kirkpatrick said: “These mince pies are the closest you can get to the real deal, the pastry and filling are far nicer than others we tried”.

What did Which? say about mince pies?

Which? had not published 2026 results when we checked on 12 November. In its 2025 test, Waitrose No1 Brown Butter Mince Pies with Cognac were “the clear favourite”, with M&S Collection Mince Pies second and Iceland Luxury All Butter Mince Pies third.

Which?’s experts rated Asda Exceptional Luxury Mince Pies “the poorest pies on test” in 2025. A year later, the Independent rated the same named pie 4/5 for its spicing, a reminder that recipes and panels change from year to year.

What is the best Christmas pudding in 2026?

The Good Housekeeping Institute tested 26 classic and flavoured puddings blind, cooked to the packet instructions. Its winner was the Aldi Specially Selected 24 Month Matured Christmas Pudding (85/100).

Good Housekeeping said: “Packed with plump vine fruit and citrus peel, it impressed our testers with its warming spice, juicy fruit and crunchy almonds.” Aldi lists the 800g pudding at £6.99, down from £7.99.

woman&home’s best traditional pudding was Morrisons The Best Christmas Pudding. Chef Nathan Outlaw, one of its guest judges, said: “This Christmas I’ll be eating this one!” The same pudding scored 70/100 with Good Housekeeping.

woman&home listed it at £5 for 800g, but Morrisons’ own site shows £9 for the 800g pudding on 12 November. Morrisons describes it as 18 month matured, with cider, rum and sherry, and laced with Cognac.

How do the 2026 Christmas puddings compare?

Christmas puddingRetailerPriceSizeWhat the testers saidSource
Specially Selected 24 Month MaturedAldi£6.99800g85/100, best Christmas pudding and best valueGood Housekeeping
Large Classic Christmas PuddingBettys£27.95*800g84/100, best luxury puddingGood Housekeeping
No.1 12 Month MaturedWaitrose£11.20*800g81/100, “Christmas Day in a pud”Good Housekeeping
The Best Limoncello And ClementineMorrisons£5.50400g78/100, best flavoured puddingGood Housekeeping
Specially Selected Tiki RumAldi£4.69 (in store from 15 November)400g76/100, “super fruity”Good Housekeeping
Luxury Christmas Pudding (organic)Abel & Cole£19.00900g76/100, best organic puddingGood Housekeeping
Guinness Christmas Pudding with Belgian ChocolateTesco£5*400g73/100, best chocolate puddingGood Housekeeping
Taste the Difference 18 Month Matured Cognac LacedSainsbury’s£6.50*400g73/100, some found it “a little dry”Good Housekeeping
Exceptional Luxury Christmas PuddingAsda£8.84*800g73/100, “really traditional” flavourGood Housekeeping
The Best Christmas PuddingMorrisons£9.00800gBest traditional pudding; 70/100 at Good Housekeepingwoman&home, Good Housekeeping
The Best Free From 6 Months Matured LuxuryMorrisons£2.00100gBest free from puddingwoman&home

Prices marked * are the prices quoted by Good Housekeeping, as we could not confirm them on the retailer’s own site. Waitrose and Asda were both shown with a temporary discount at the time.

Which Christmas pudding should you buy if you do not like Christmas pudding?

Good Housekeeping’s answer is the Tesco Guinness Christmas Pudding with Belgian Chocolate, which it called “the perfect Christmas pudding for those who don’t like Christmas pudding”.

For something lighter and still traditional in shape, Morrisons’ limoncello and clementine pudding was described by testers as “a good balance between traditional and flavoured”. Aldi’s Tiki Rum pudding, with notes of butterscotch and caramel, was called “a lighter, crowd-pleasing take on traditional Christmas pudding”.

What is the best gluten-free Christmas pudding?

woman&home’s free from winner was the Morrisons The Best Free From 6 Months Matured Luxury Christmas Pudding, a single-serve 100g pud that Morrisons sells for £2. Nathan Outlaw said: “With good fruit content, this one’s nicely tender, not as tough as other gluten free options”.

How should you heat a shop-bought Christmas pudding and mince pies?

Which? advises steaming rather than microwaving your pudding. In its Christmas pudding guide it says microwaving can make the fat separate too quickly, “leaving you with a dry pudding”. Which? adds that most packs recommend steaming for one to two hours.

Mince pies are better warm, too. Which?’s experts were served pies warm from the oven, and woman&home said Tesco’s Jewelled Mince Pie Tarts “really shine when warmed”. If you would rather make your own, here is how to bake mince pies at home.

When will these mince pies and puddings be in the shops?

Most are on sale now, but a few have later start dates. Aldi lists its Tiki Rum pudding as in store from Sunday 15 November, and Morrisons lists The Best Signature Collection Mince Pies (78/100 at Good Housekeeping, £2 for two) as available from late November.

Good Housekeeping also scored Aldi’s Specially Selected The Ultimate Brown Butter Mince Pies 84/100 for the butteriest pastry of its test, and said they will be available from 22 November 2026. They were not yet listed on Aldi’s website when we checked.

If you are ordering online, book early: our guides cover Tesco Christmas delivery slots for 2026 and Waitrose Christmas delivery slots.

Is Christmas pudding still worth buying?

It remains one of the dishes people feel most strongly about. It came second only to pigs in blankets in one poll of the UK’s most nostalgic Christmas foods.

The good news from the 2026 tests is that the top-rated pudding is also one of the cheapest. That leaves more of the budget for the rest of the meal, and for getting the roast potatoes properly crisp. If you are buying edible presents too, see our guide to food gifts and hampers worth giving this Christmas.

How we put this guide together

FEAST has not tasted these products. Every rating and quote comes from the published taste tests linked above, and we have kept each test’s own wording. Where a test’s year is not 2026, we say so.

Prices were checked on 12 November 2026 on the retailers’ own websites for Aldi, Morrisons and Abel & Cole. Tesco, Sainsbury’s, Waitrose, Asda, Co-op, Ocado, Bettys and Brownie and the Bean product pages could not be loaded for our check, so for those we show the price quoted by the testers, marked with an asterisk. There are no affiliate links in this article.

Feast Magazine

News and features from the FEAST Magazine editorial team.

More from Feast Magazine →